Marketing/Acquisition

Meta Ads or Google Ads? The right question is: does the demand already exist?

Comparing ad platforms by cost per click is comparing tools built for different jobs. A more useful way to decide: capturing demand or creating demand.

Murilo Anzini 3 min read

"Which is better, Meta or Google?" is one of the questions I hear most from people starting to invest in paid media. The honest answer is: it depends on whether demand for your product already exists. The two platforms do different jobs, and comparing their cost per click is like comparing the price of a hammer with the price of a screwdriver.

Capturing demand vs. creating demand

Google Ads (search) captures demand. The person already knows they have a problem, is already looking for a solution and types it into the search bar. Your ad shows up at the moment of intent. It's the channel closest to conversion there is, which is why it tends to be expensive on competitive keywords.

Meta Ads creates demand. The person is scrolling the feed, not looking for anything. Your ad interrupts, presents a problem (or a solution they didn't know existed) and sparks interest. The click is cheaper, but the person is further from buying.

Google Ads (search)Meta Ads
IntentHigh: the person searchedLow to medium: the person was reached
TargetingBy what the person searches forBy profile, interest and lookalikes
CreativeText, the right word mattersImage and video, the hook matters
Best forKnown category, a problem with a nameNew category, visual product, impulse
RiskExpensive auctions on competitive termsCheap traffic that doesn't convert

How to decide where to start

Ask three questions about your product:

  1. Do people search for this? Open the keyword planner or just search for the problem you solve. If there's search volume with buying intent ("performance review software", "clinic management system"), there's demand to capture.
  2. Is the category new? If you're creating a new way to solve something, nobody will search for the name you gave it. You'll need to explain the problem first, and that's demand creation work.
  3. Does the product explain itself in three seconds of video? Visual products with a clear "before and after" do very well in the feed.
For most B2B SaaS in a known category, the order that tends to work is: Google search to capture people already looking, and Meta for remarketing and educating the market once basic conversion is validated.

What few people measure: the cost of an activated customer

The most expensive mistake in paid media is optimizing the wrong metric. Cost per click and cost per sign-up are platform metrics. What matters to the business is the cost per customer who reached value (activated, paid, stayed).

It's common for a Meta campaign to have a much lower cost per sign-up than a Google one and, at the same time, a much higher cost per activated customer, because the audience came out of curiosity and didn't have the pain. Without measuring all the way to activation, you end up scaling exactly the wrong campaign.

To do that math, the minimum is:

  • Consistent UTMs on every ad link;
  • The activation event (not just the sign-up) sent to analytics and, if possible, back to the platforms (offline conversions or the Conversions API);
  • A report that connects channel → sign-up → activation → payment.

Creative is the new targeting

With targeting increasingly automated by the platforms themselves, the biggest lever left for you is the creative. On Meta, the algorithm uses the ad itself to find the people interested in it. That means:

  • Testing different angles (pain, outcome, objection, proof) matters more than testing audiences;
  • Each angle attracts a different kind of person, so the creative is also a positioning decision;
  • Volume of variations matters: a handful of creatives wears out fast.

On Google, the equivalent is the match between the search, the ad and the page. If the person searched for "360 review for small businesses", the ad and the page need to talk about exactly that.

Summary

There's no better platform, only different jobs. If the demand exists, capture it where it shows up: in search. If it doesn't, create it where attention is: in the feed. And either way, measure all the way to the activated customer, because that's where the money shows up (or disappears).

#paid-traffic#meta-ads#google-ads#acquisition

Murilo Anzini

Hands-on writing on engineering, product, data and marketing for people who want to understand, and build, the whole journey of a product.

About me

Free ebook

Criando infoprodutos de valor

The method I use to bring product, marketing and sales together when creating digital products: the way startups test hypotheses, understand needs and build what the market wants to buy.

  • Understand the customer and set the initial hypotheses
  • Build and test a lean MVP
  • Measure progress and validate with data
  • Know when and how to pivot
Download for freePDF · 23 pages · in Portuguese · no sign-up